Transcript 0:00 In 2012, a graduate student in Toronto named Alex Krizhevsky was working out of his bedroom at his parents' house. 0:06 He had two video game cards plugged into his computer, the kind a teenager saves up for so their games look better, about $500 each. 0:14 He was trying to teach a computer to look at a photo and tell you what's in it, like a dog, a car, a mushroom. 0:21 The best scientists in the world had been working on that for years at the biggest universities and tech companies, and at that point, they were only inching forward. 0:30 Now, he let those two gaming cards run for about five days, and then he entered the result in the biggest image recognition contest in the world. And he didn't just win. He beat everybody by more than 10 points. 0:44 It wasn't even close. But the other student he built it with, Ilya Sutskever, went on to co-found OpenAI, the company behind ChatGPT. Their professor, Geoffrey Hinton, went on to win a Nobel Prize. 0:59 Now, a lot of people say that bedroom is where the AI boom started, and the company that made those two little gaming cards was called NVIDIA. 1:07 Now, 13 years later, NVIDIA became the first company in history worth $5 trillion. 1:13 The US and China are now fighting over its chips like they're weapons, and this week, the man who built it, Jensen Huang, is out after 33 years over an affair and a woman that US intelligence reportedly believed was working for China. 1:29 So how does a company that made video game cards end up in the middle of a spy story? And who's actually getting rich off of it? Welcome to The Observation Room. 1:40 I am your host, Michelle Vaughn, and hopefully, today, I give you a little change in perspective. Now, I wanna tell you right now, I have a very strong feeling about the cheating part, and I'll get there. 1:53 But you canna- you can't understand why anybody would spy over a computer chip until you see the whole picture and actually what it does. So let's start there. 2:03 The best explanation I've ever seen came from the MythBusters guys, Adam Savage and Jamie Hyneman, back in 2008. NVIDIA brought them to do a demo at its own conference, so keep that in mind. But it's a great picture. 2:18 They rolled out a robot that painted a smiley face on canvas by shooting paintballs one at a time. Shoot, move a little, shoot again, move a little, shoot again, and it took a while. 2:29 That robot was a CPU, the main chip in every computer you've ever used. It's smart, it's fast, but it works through things like one after the other, the way you'd work through a to-do list. 2:40 Then they rolled out the second robot. It was a giant rack of over paintball barrels, over a thousand of them, all aimed at the canvas, and they all fired at once. In a fraction of a second, there was the Mona Lisa. 2:54 That robot was a GPU, and that is what NVIDIA makes: thousands of small, simple workers that take a problem, chop it into tiny pieces, and do all of them at the same time. That's the whole idea. 3:06 Same paint, same canvas, completely different way of getting it done. Now, why would any, not, anybody need a thousand paintball guns? Video games. That's where it all started. 3:17 A game screen is made of a million tiny dots, and every single one of those dots needs the sim- same simple math done to it many times every second, so the picture can move. 3:27 A brain chip doing that one dot at a time could never keep up, so NVIDIA built a chip that does all the dots at once. And for years, that's what NVIDIA was: a video game company. 3:38 If you had ever, ever had a gaming computer in the 2000s, there's a good chance it said GeoForce on it or GeForce on it somewhere. 3:46 And then it turned out that that artificial intelligence runs almost exactly the same kind of math. 3:52 NVIDIA itself describes an AI model as a mathematical lasagna, layer after layer of the same simple calculations, billions of them, over and over. It's not one genius problem. 4:05 It's a mountain of tiny, boring ones that all need doing at the same exact time, which is exactly what a chip built for video games was already so good at. 4:14 I think that's one of the most interesting things about the whole story, and it's why I can't just look at NVIDIA as just a stock. 4:21 A company built a thing for kids to play video games, and 20 years later, it turned out that same thing was the engine for the most important technology in the world as we know it today. 4:32 Nobody had planned for that, not, not even them, at least not at first. So how did they get here? Because it was... It wasn't a straight line, and honestly, it almost didn't happen at all. 4:42 NVIDIA was started in 1993 by three engineers: Jensen Huang, Chris, Chris Malowski, and Curtis Priem, with about $40,000 of their own money. Now, their very first chip came out, um, in 1995, uh, and it flopped. 4:58 They built it to draw pictures using curved surfaces, and right around the same time, the rest of the industry, including Microsoft, decided everybody was going to draw with triangles instead. 5:07 So NVIDIA had bet on the wrong shape. Developers didn't w- wanna work with it, and they stopped selling it. At the same time, they were building a chip for Sega's next video game console. 5:18 Partway through, they realized that design was wrong, too. Jensen has told this story himself. He went to Sega and went to an executive who later became Sega's president, and they... 5:30 and basically told him, "Hey, we can't do this the way we promised you. You should probably go find someone else." 5:35 And then he asked Sega to pay him anyway, because if they didn't, NVIDIA was going to go under, and Sega did. Paid them. They turned their last payment, about $5 million, into an investment in NVIDIA. 5:49 Jensen has said that money gave him six months to live, the company, and those six months are the reason that NVIDIA still exists today. I love that story because it's really how business works. 6:00 And It, it wasn't like a contract. That was one person deciding to be kind to another person who had just told him the truth about his failure. 6:10 This past July, about 30 years later, the two of them met up again at an arcade in Tokyo. Now, Jensen has... 6:18 also has a line that he's been repeating for decades: "We are 30 days away from going out of business," even when they were huge and profitable. 6:25 He said it on Joe G- Joe Rogan's last show that he has been saying it for over 33 years. Now, I don't know if that was ever literally true down to the day, but I do understand why he kept saying it. 6:36 When you've been that close to losing everything, you never quite stop feeling it. 6:40 So after the flop, they built a new chip, this time using triangles, after cutting the company from about 100 people to 40, with the money almost gone, and it was a hit. 6:52 They sold about a million of them in the first four months, and in 1999 they put out the GeForce 256, and they called it the world's first GPU. Now, that was a marketing line. 7:03 People argue to this day about whether it was really the first one. But NVIDIA named the category, and then they owned it, and there's a business lesson in that in by itself. 7:13 Then in 2006, they unveiled something called CUDA. 7:17 It's fr- a free software that lets regular programmers use those thousands of little GPU workers for anything, not just video games and pictures, science, math, research, whatever you want. 7:28 And NVIDIA put it on every single chip they sold, even the cheap gaming ones that teenager- teenagers bought. It was expensive, and for years it didn't pay off. 7:39 Jensen has said it raised the company's cost by about 50% at that time, when they didn't have that much margin to spare. 7:45 So why is a video game company spending all of this money on a software scientists might use someday? 7:51 The stock lost about three-quarters of its value in 2008, and for years after, the company's sales basically went sideways. Jensen has said it took a decade. 8:02 And then came the bedroom in Toronto in 2012, Alex, Ilya, and their professor who wrote the whole thing using CUDA. Now, that's the moment. 8:12 That's when people building artificial intelligence realized the engine they had needed had been sitting in gaming computers the whole time. Dylan would love this story. 8:21 And because NVIDIA had spent all those years putting CUDA chip on every single chip, millions of students and researchers already knew how to use it. Every new AI program got built on top of it, and that's what I... 8:33 what people mean when they talk about NVIDIA's moat. It's not only that their chips are fast, it's that the whole world learned to build software on... 8:42 build it on their software, and switching to somebody else means rebuilding everything. So that's how they got here. Now, how do they make money today? Because the numbers are almost really hard to believe sometimes. 8:53 The first thing is to understand that NVIDIA doesn't actually make its chips. It designs them. The building, the actual manufacturing, is done mostly by a company called TSMC in Taiwan. 9:07 And Taiwan is where most of the world's m- most advanced chips get made, period. Like, one industry study put it at 92% of the most advanced chip-making capacity in the world a- as of, like, I think 2019. 9:21 A newer study had put it about two-thirds of that in 2022, and the US is trying to build more here. 9:28 NVIDIA announced it would produce up to about $500 billion worth of AI equipment in America over four years, and the first American-made wafer for one of its newest chips came out of TSMC's factory in Phoenix years later. 9:41 But even those had to be shipped back to Taiwan for the final step. So when you hear people talk about Taiwan and China and why it matters so much, this is a big part of the why. 9:51 Now, the chips the whole AI economy runs on mostly come from one island. Now, the second thing is who actually buys them. 10:00 NVIDIA's biggest customers are the t- giant tech companies, Microsoft, Google, Amazon, Meta, and a few others. 10:07 Now, building an enormous data center full of these chips, those four companies together are expected to spend around $730 billion this year on buildings and equipment, and a lot of it for AI. 10:21 Now, that's one year, and NVIDIA's own filings show how concentrated that is. In the first half of this year, just three direct customers made up 44% of NVIDIA's revenue. 10:33 NVIDIA doesn't name them, of course, and some of them are the companies that put the server... that... the servers together for the big tech firms. But think about what that means. 10:42 Almost half the money comes from three buyers, and here's what that adds up to. In the second quarter ended in that July that just ended, NVIDIA bought about $96 billion in revenue i- it brought in in three months. 10:57 That's more than double the year before, and about 92% of that came from data centers, meaning AI. And out of that $96 billion, they kept about $60 billion as profit. Their gross margin was 75%. 11:09 For every dollar of chips they sell, about 75 cents of it is left after the cost of making them. Now, that's not a normal number. 11:17 That's the kinda number you get when you're basically the only one selling what everybody needs. And that's how it got to $5 trillion last year. Now, right now, after this week, it's back to around $4 trillion. 11:28 Apple has passed it again, and Microsoft briefly did too, and that changes every day, obviously. 11:33 But there's one more piece to how the money works that I want people to understand because it's the thing that critics keep pointing at. NVIDIA has started its own investing in its own customers. 11:45 It put $30 billion into OpenAI earlier this year. It committed up to $10 billion to Anthropic. It agreed to buy any computing power that a company called CoreWeave can't sell, up to $6.3 billion through 2032 12:03 And those companies, of course, buy NVIDIA chips. Some very famous investors... Now let's, uh, uh, look at, and see that as a warning sign. 12:12 So Michael Burry, the guy from The Big Short, has compared NVIDIA to Cisco in the dot-com bubble, a supplier that helped pump up its own demand. 12:21 Other critics, like the short seller Jim Chanos, point to Lucent around 2000, which lent money to its own customers so they could buy its equipment, and that ended really badly. So NVIDIA pushed back really hard on that. 12:34 Now, last year, it sent a memo to its analysts saying that its investments are tiny compared to its sales, and that doesn't really re-rely on the kind of finance the way Lucent did. Now, I don't know who's right yet. 12:47 I don't think anybody does. But I think it's worth noticing and taking note. 12:50 Now, when the company selling the sh- the shovels is also handing out the money to the people buying the shovels, you have to ask, you know, how much of the gold rush is really real? 13:00 Okay, let's talk about China, because this is the part people really get confused the most about, I think, and it's at the center of everything that happened last week. 13:08 Now, a few years ago, China was a huge market for NVIDIA. Before the restrictions, China and Hong Kong were about a quarter of NVIDIA's sales. 13:18 Now then, in 2022, the US government said that these chips are powerful enough to help a, help a military, and we don't want China to have the best ones. 13:27 So NVIDIA had to get permission to sell its top chips there, and mostly the answer was no. So NVIDIA did what a business does. It made slower versions of those chips just under the line, just specifically for China. 13:43 And then the government moved the line. So NVIDIA made another one called the H20. 13:48 Then, in April of last year, the government said that that one needed permission, too, which basically stopped it, and NVIDIA had to write off about $4.5 billion, 13:57 and it couldn't ship another 2.5 billion that quarter either. 14:01 So in May, Jensen stood on stage in Taiwan and said that the export controls were a failure, and that NVIDIA's share of China's market had already dropped from 95% to about half. Then in August, a strange deal. 14:15 Trump stood up at a news conference at the White House and said that Jensen wanted permission to sell a chip called the H20 in China again. And Trump said he had told him, "Fine, but you're going to pay us as a country." 14:28 And then he said he asked for 20%, and Jensen haggled him down to 15. The President of the United States haggling with a CEO over a cut of a chip sales to China, and Trump even called the, the chip obsolete. 14:42 Now think about that. How, how unusual is that? Now, a lot of people asked, "If this chip is dangerous, why are we even selling it? And if it isn't, why are we charging a fee?" I don't know. 14:53 According to NVIDIA's own annual report, under that deal, NVIDIA only made about $60 million, not billion, million. Because by then, China had already started telling its own companies not to buy. 15:05 And it's not only the US saying no. China said no too now. Now, Beijing told companies like Alibaba and ByteDance to stop buying certain NVIDIA chips. It told new government-funded data centers to use only Chinese chips. 15:19 Now, by October of last year, Jensen had said that NVIDIA's share of China's AI chips market had gone from 95% to 0. 15:28 Uh, then in December, the US said NVIDIA could sell an even better chip to, the H200, to its approved buyers, with the US taking about 25%. 15:39 And China's customers officials told the agents those chips weren't, weren't allowed in. Now, later, Beijing let a few small approved batches through. 15:47 In NVIDIA's most recent quarter, sales of what that chip to China were less than 1% of its data center business. In NVIDIA's own forecast for the quarter it reports next week assumes zero data centers sales in China. 16:02 So on paper, the front door to China is basically closed from both sides, which brings us back to the back door. Now, because even with all those rules, the chips kept getting into China. 16:12 Now, last November, four men were charged in the US with allegedly plotting to sneak restricted NVIDIA chips into China using a front company and routing them through Malaysia, a- Malaysia and Thailand. 16:25 And one research group, Epic AI, estimated that by the end of last year, somewhere between about 300,000 and 1.6 million of NVIDIA's top chips' worth of computing power had been smuggled into China. 16:38 Their middle guess is around 660,000, which would roughly be a third of all China's computing, AI computing power. So when something is that valuable and that restricted, it will find a way, 16:52 and that's where this week's story comes in. So here's what has been reported thus far. 16:58 Uh, I'm gonna be precise about all this because almost all the serious allegations coming from anonymous sources, and some of that will probably be turned out to be wrong. 17:08 Uh, okay, so there's a businesswoman named Alice Huang. She is a Chinese citizen, and she is not related to Jensen. It's just a common name there. 17:17 According to NBC, she started out as a TV reporter for a Chinese state media, moved into finance, and then video games. 17:24 In 2023, she was the managing director of a company called Megaspeed based in Singapore, which Bloomberg has called NVIDIA's biggest partner in Southeast Asia. 17:35 The first New York Times story came out in October, uh, the October 29th. 17:40 It's the one that said that US intelligence saw her as a Chinese asset, and it added that President Trump has already been briefed on this before, about a year earlier. 17:50 And then on November 6th, The Times reported on a classified memo saying a China spy agency had recruited her, and the Financial Times reported that the memo described a romantic relationship. 18:01 Two days later, The Times reported that the Secretary of State, Marco Rubio, had overseen that memo back in the spring. Now, all of that comes down to, uh, from people who weren't named. 18:13 So NB- NBC has said her exact role is still unclear and that she may not even be a, a, a career spy. She's never commented publicly. 18:23 She hasn't been charged with anything anywhere, and China's foreign ministry calls the whole thing a smear campaign. Singapore is the one place that has said anything effect- has anything official about her. 18:35 Its police started looking into Megaspeed in February of last year. 18:39 They interviewed her that June and took her passport, and in February of this year, they decided there wasn't enough evidence that she actually committed any crimes. 18:48 But they did say that she had n- knowingly given them inaccurate information to downplay her role, and they gave her a stern warning, and they even barred her from coming back into the country. 18:58 Now, they only made that public this week, and they said that very clearly, that they never investigated her for spying. 19:05 Now, Megaspeed itself is under a US criminal investigation for allegedly smuggling American chips into China, according to NBC, and no one has actually been charged with this. 19:17 The, the company says it takes export rules extremely seriously and will cooperate. 19:22 Now, last December, Bloomberg used custom records, uh, custom records to report that Megaspeed and its affiliates brought in at least $4.6 billion of NVIDIA hardware since 2023. 19:34 The $7.5 billion report on Tuesday came from a tech publication called The Information. It said that the network tied to her family moved about 240,000 chips. That report doesn't say Jensen directed any of that, though. 19:49 Now, again, it's unnamed sources, so I'm treating it as a, a report and not as facts. Now, here's what's on the record. So on Sunday, Jensen told his employees that he was unfaithful to his wife. 20:02 Now, he didn't name anyone. 20:04 He mentioned the national security concerns in the news and said that he supports the board's investigation, and he said that he's proud to be an American, but he didn't respond to the spy allegation. 20:14 Now, the, the board said it had no reason to believe that national security or company secrets were actually compromised, and a few days later, it hired a former acting US attorney to run the investigation. 20:27 On Monday, President Trump said the FBI was looking into it and that Jensen told him that he had no idea she was a spy, and Trump said that he actually believed him. 20:36 Now, the stock fell about 4% that day and about 5.5% on Tuesday, although Tuesday was just a bad m- market day for, for everyone. 20:47 So the Times story on Wednesday about the second relationship cited five people who worked at NVIDIA. Now, I'm not naming her because it's all anonymous sources and we don't have any facts. Nobody's been tried yet. 20:57 Now, that night, the board accepted his resignation. So on Thursday morning, NVIDIA announced that Jensen has resigned as CEO, as president, and from the board, effective immediately. 21:09 The Chief Financial Officer, Colette Kress, is now interim CEO. Now, a spokesperson made it clear he's not staying on in any role. He didn't put out a statement of his own either. 21:20 He still owns about 3.5% of the company, well worth over $100 billion, and the stock opened down more than 12% Thursday morning before it clawed back some of that. So four days from we have confidence in him to gone. 21:37 I'll be honest with you, the gossip part, I didn't really care about his personal life at all. The affair, of course, is a different topic for me. 21:44 I don't really trust anyone who cheats on their spouse because I think you're just not trust- trustworthy person. Like, you can't even keep a promise to yourself. So I'm against cheating as a whole. 21:54 I, I, I pr- I don't do business with people who cheat on their wives or husbands. If, um... I, I have literally left people over this in the past. 22:02 Like, I had a, a realtor partner that cheated on their h- their spouse, and they, uh, they called me about it and told me about it, and I, I couldn't work with them anymore because 22:13 i- if that person can cheat on their spouse, why wouldn't they screw me over? I don't know. I just can't trust you. I don't wanna do business with you. That's just me. 22:20 So to me, it's incredible that you can build all of that and then have everything taken away because of that. But something's wrong if you cheat, in my mind. 22:28 Um, something's just not connecting, and you need to go heal it. I, I mean, I have a lot of personal issues that I have... I've been work-- I try to work on h- healing all of them. 22:38 Um, so I'm not judging, but I, I do judge who I associate with, so maybe it is judging. I don't know. I'm okay saying that I'm judgmental about that. I don't wanna work with people who cheat on their spouse. 22:47 So does a CEO's personal life matter? Uh, I think 1,000,000%. I've seen it in my own companies, my own life. When my personal life started falling apart, my company started falling apart. 22:57 And then the real question for any business is, like, when bad things happen to the person at the top, and they, they will happen, can the, can the company survive it? And that's what I'm trying to build now. 23:07 It's why I'm not just bringing a bunch of people on board and, and, and all of my stuff. I r- I'm raising my own capital. 23:12 I'm using my own savings not to go in, um, not going in any debt, and I'm building my companies from cash. 23:18 So I've actually saved because the way I live, way below my means now, and I want that to be something I, that I can get over the hump when life will happen, 'cause it will. 23:26 [coughs] For me, the affair would be enough on its own. But for the rest of the world, this one's much bigger because it sits right on top of the most valuable product on Earth, 23:40 the exact chips one government is trying to keep away from another, and a customer that's under investigation for doing just that. 23:47 Now, whether or not Alice Huang is a spy and whether or not a single chip moved because of her, the question that ended his run is the same one I ask about anybody: Can I trust you? 24:01 Now, NVIDIA gets to find out whether or not it was built to survive because the person at the top, 'cause Jensen did build something really real, the Sega story, the CUDA bet, sticking with it for 10 years while it wasn't paying off, and that all happened. 24:15 Now, and this week too I can respect what he built and still not want to do business with him, right? 24:21 Now, I don't agree with affairs, you know that, and I'd be lying if I said this whole thing didn't feel a little off to me, though. So I wanna ask some real questions. Now I don't... 24:29 Of course, I don't have to prove anything. These are just questions, and I think it, uh, uh, wouldn't be fair if I didn't ask them. First, why him? And why now? 24:38 A lot of powerful men have cheated on their wives and kept their jobs or been accused of being in the Epstein files, right? We've watched powerful people connected to things way worse 24:48 being on the Epstein list, and they stay right where they are. So why does this one end a 33-year run in four days? Seems susp- suspicious. Now, to be fair, there's a difference here. 24:59 The second relationship was reported with an executive who reported directly to him, and a lot of companies have rules about that, and it's cost other CEOs their jobs, too. 25:07 McDonald's fired its CEO in 2019 over a relationship with an employee. Intel's CEO resigned in 2018 over that one. So i- that's not new, but here's my next question: Who benefits from Jensen being gone? 25:22 He was the loudest voice in the country fighting the limits on selling chips to China. He was the one pushing the White House to let NVIDIA sell there. 25:31 In the same week this broke, hmm, the lawmakers who wanted tighter rules on those chips got all the momentum they needed to push their bills. Anybody betting against NVIDIA stock made money when it dropped. 25:45 And every company trying to catch NVIDIA just watched it lose the man who built it. I'm not saying anybody planned this. I am saying that. I'm pretty sure it was planned. 25:53 [laughs] Um, a lot of people are better off with him gone. And who benefits if these chips are so dangerous and that, like, a spy would wanna get to them? Why is the President letting NVIDIA sell them to China? 26:06 As long as the government got a cut. That's weird. The storylines don't add up for me. And one more thing, Jensen is Taiwanese American. 26:14 The woman at the center of this is a Chinese citizen, and this country has a history here. 26:19 Starting in 2018, the Justice Department ran something called the China Initiative to go after a Chinese spying, and it ended in 2022. 26:28 Now, after a lot of criticism that it was leading to racial profiling, and even before that, there were people like Sherry Chen, a hydrologist at the National Weather Service, and, uh, a physics professor at Temple University who were charged in China-related cases and then later had their charges dropped. 26:47 Their lives got turned upside down. So would this have played out as the same way for a CEO who wasn't Asian? I don't know. I honestly don't know. Maybe the answer is yes. But I think it's a fair question to ask. 27:00 And who benefits is always the question I come back to. So back to the question I started with: Who actually benefits? I'll be honest. When I started, I d- I didn't know. I wanted... I, I... 27:13 So I researched it, and I, I had to prove myself before I could even say it. And that's what I wanted this whole episode to discover. Let me tell you where I started from. So you know my bias. 27:25 I don't love the government coming in and telling people who they can and can't sell to. If national security is a real risk, that does matter. 27:32 So however, I, I do believe that a lot of this stuff is really just them using fear as control to make themselves more rich. So that's the thing. Is there a real risk? That's the part I don't believe. 27:45 If I'm telling you the truth of how I feel about it is that's more than anything. So I went looking down both sides. The case that the risk is real goes like this: The most advanced 27:58 AI can help the military with surveillance, help with weapons, help the US... And the US wants to stay ahead, of course. 28:06 The chair, the House Committee on China, John Moolenaar, who's actually from Michigan, has been one of the loudest voices on this. 28:13 Earlier this year, his committee said that NVIDIA had given DeepSeek, the Chinese AI company, a lot of technical help and that DeepSeek's AI is now used in Chinese military systems. NVIDIA disputes that, and, uh, 28:27 he, he acknowledged himself there was no p- public evidence of military ties back when NVIDIA was helping. 28:33 Elizabeth Warren said that selling the H200 risked turbocharging China's bid for technological and military dominance. Maybe there's real evidence China military wants these chips. I don't know. 28:45 Researchers who went through Chinese military purchasing records found hundreds of requests for American AI chips, including NVIDIA's, and on Wednesday, Reuters reported that a military-linked university is, tha- that's on a US blacklist bought two of NVIDIA's H200s in September. 29:01 And then there's this week. If the reporting is right, and that's a big if, China wanted these chips so badly enough to go after the CE- he, the CEO himself. 29:11 Bills to track where these chips go once they leave the country were already moving before all of this, and lawmakers from both parties are now using it this week to push them through. 29:23 Now, this case against goes like this, and, and Jensen was the loudest voice on it. Blocking sales doesn't stop China, though. 29:31 It just forces China to build its own chips and hands China-owned companies, mainly Huawei, a giant market with no competition. It's weird. 29:42 The, the White House's own AI advisor, David Sacks, has made a version of that argument, and then there's the part that sounds exactly like what I was saying about fear and money. 29:51 The government didn't just say these chips were too dangerous. It said, "You can sell them if we get 15%." That's weird. And then it was 25%. 30:02 Now, Commerce Secretary Harold Lutnick even said that the goal was to get Chinese developers addicted to m- American technology. Now, if a chip is real danger, why are you selling it for a cut? 30:14 A lot of people on both sides asked this exact same question. So I followed the money, and here's what I found. Nvidia and the American si-side came out ahead by a lot. 30:26 China used to be 20 to 25% of N-Nvidia's data center business, and then that basically went to zero. Nvidia's revenue still more than doubled in a year. The American tech companies bought everything China couldn't. 30:39 Nvidia's own forecast for this quarter doesn't even count on China. In plain money, the restrictions barely slowed Nvidia down, and its shareholders and the American companies building AI are the ones who got rich. Hmm. 30:53 The US government, the ones writing the rules, the taxpayers, got nothing. Remember the 15% Trump haggled over? About $60 million in sales under those licenses, which means about $9 million for the government, 31:09 if it was ever paid. I couldn't find any public record that it was. Never paid. Taxpayers lose again. 31:15 Nvidia's report says that arrangement was never even written down into a regulation, and that 25% deal on the H200 covered less than 1% of Nvidia's data center sales. 31:24 So if the government was using fear to make money, it did a terrible job of collecting it. Now, China lost the front door, but it didn't lose everything. 31:34 Now remember that estimate, maybe a third of China's AI computing power coming through the back door? DeepSeek built a model that scared the whole stock market. 31:45 Now, even though its own founder has said his biggest problem wasn't money, it was the chip ban, and China's own chip makers got exactly what they needed: a reason for the whole country to buy from them. 31:59 Hawaii now has its, a new AI chip on its roadmap every single year through 2028. You could argue that the restrictions did exactly what Jensen said they would do. They would give China a reason to stop needing us. 32:12 Taiwan TSMC benefit no matter who wins, 'cause everybody, including Nvidia's competitors, still needs the ch-chips. They still need them, Taiwan, to build the chips. The middleman benefited. 32:26 Now, remember that Bloomberg found from custom records at least 4.6 billion of Nvidia hardware going through Megaspeed and its affiliates. Now, when something is worth more than 32:37 on the other side of the border, someone will always be willing to carry it. So here's what the evidence says, at least so far, in dollars. The American side won. 32:47 Nvidia, its shareholders, and American tech companies all won. Over the long run, China's own chip industry may be the biggest winner, 32:56 but time will tell, 'cause it forced Chinese to invest in their own, and the government that wrote the rules got the least of it. On my question why the risk is even real here, here's what I found. 33:09 The risk is probably real, but it's smaller than the loudest people made it get sound. 33:13 China's military has kept trying to buy these chips year after year, but the purchases anyone has actually documented are dozens of chips, and a serious AI system uses 100,000 of them. 33:25 A request on a purchasing list isn't really proof they were ever used for anything. The bigger leak is the smuggling, and if the reporting holds up, a real attempt to get close to the man at the top. This is not nothing. 33:37 The government showed it was willing to sell danger for a fee. The commerce secretary said out loud that the goal was to get China addicted, and Beijing used security as its excuse to push Nvidia out and protect Huawei. 33:54 Now, everybody in this fight, Nvidia, the hawks in Washington, and the government in Beijing, has a real reason to make the risk sound bigger or smaller than it is. Now, both of those things are true at the same time. 34:07 Who pays? The people holding the stock this week, 34:11 Nvidia's employees who are all watching this play out in the news, Jensen's family, who he said bear no responsibility for his choices, and honestly, all of us a little bit. 34:21 Because when there were three customers make up almost half of a, one company's sales and that company sits in nearly every retirement account in the country, a lot of normal people are tied to whether they know it or not. 34:35 If they, if you have an index fund, you probably own some Nvidia. Whether you buy Nvidia, sell it, or never think about it again, it's completely still your business. And that's not what this episode is for. 34:48 After a week like this, through these things, I kept turning over in my own head. Do I actually understand what the companies everybody's talking about do, or do I just know their names? 34:59 But my suspicion has evidence too. The government showed it was willing to sell the danger for a fee. 35:05 The commerce secretary said out loud the goal was to get China addicted, and Beijing used security as an excuse to push Nvidia out and protect Huawei. 35:14 Everybody in this fight, Nvidia, the hawks in Washington, and the government in Beijing, has a reason to make the risk sound bigger or smaller than it is. Now, both of those things are true at the same time. 35:27 But who pays? 35:28 The people holding the stock this week, Nvidia employees who are all watching this play out in the news, Jensen's family, who he said bear no responsibility for his choices, and honestly, all of us a little bit. 35:41 Because when three customers make up almost half of one company's sales and that company sits at nearly every retirement account in the country, a lot of normal people like you and me are tied to whether they know this or not. 35:56 If you have an index fund, you've probably owned some Nvidia. Whether you buy Nvidia, sell it, or never think about it, again, is completely your business. That's not what this episode is about. 36:08 Now, after a week like this, though, these things I keep turning over in my own head. Do I actually understand what the companies everybody's talking about do, or do I just know their names? 36:19 If almost half of a company's money comes from three customers, is that strength or is that a risk? 36:26 Now, when I hear a big, scary headline, do I know which parts are confirmed and which are s-part are somebody's anonymous source? 36:35 When a country tries to keep something away from another country, who ends up building it instead? Would I do business with someone I couldn't trust at home? 36:44 When I started reading about this, I thought I was gonna tell you a story about a scandal, and there is one, obviously. 36:51 But the bigger story is that a company that started out making video games ended up at the center of a fight between two of the most powerful countries in the world, and one man was standing right where all of it met. 37:05 The chips will keep getting made. Somebody will keep buying them. The question is, who gets to decide where they go, and who benefits when they do? I'm Michelle Vaughn, and this is The Observation Room. 37:21 Now, if you've stayed this long and you wanna learn more or be a part of my community, please join me at michellevaughan.co. 37:28 You can subscribe, join the community, choose whichever newsletter fits what you're interested in. We talk about finance and business and life and everything in between. I would love to have you. See you next week